Web Culture 2.0: Made in Silicon Valley
In this day and age we outsiders get a look inside to the cabal that makes up the current web culture. And like so many cliques, they spend a lot of time watching/talking about each other. Scoble talks about TechCrunch, Twitter and Techmeme almost like these are the only things worth using. That is, he applies a certain amount of importance to these sites that seems directly proportional to his involvement/visibility in these sites. Sites Scoble can't get front-and-center on, he just can't be bothered with you know? Scoble doesn't get the love from Technorati, so it's all yesterday's technology and surely it's a site dwindling in importance and not nearly as important or relevant as Techmeme.
The Tale of the Tape: technorati.com vs techmeme.com
So scoble doesn't dig the 'rait. Big deal. He's an insider, the guy with a finger on the pulse. Surely he's all right? Yet, comparing these two at alexa.com tells this tale:
...So Scoble has a point in that Technorati's reach is dwindling. ButTechmeme, his choice for up-and-comer has simply changed little-to-none in the past year. I've seen rain-puddles with more activity. Yet if you were to read his blog, one would think that Techmeme is as popular or better than Technorati. I certainly thought so until I went to alexa.com.
This I feel, is what makes Scoble seem inward looking. If his friends don't hang out there, it's no place he wants to be. Just a feeling. Not personally knowing the guy I have little to judge him on but his own blog posts.
Hang On, the Title Says "Dave Winer is Cool"
No doubt in my mind, Dave Winer is one of those guys who is on that same inside track as Scoble. Heck, he blogs about Scoble's blogs and vice-versa. Winer also spends a lot of time being active in, and talking about being in, the Twitterverse.
But, in spite of Winer and Scoble's similar M.O.'s, Winer still differs in at least one way that this post illustrates nicely:
"Dare Obasanjo, who works at Microsoft, says that..."
...the rest doesn't really matter. What impressed me was here's one of those insiders actually blogging about someone they don't really know, just because they had something interesting to say. That's it. That's why Dave is cool. He's the insider that takes the time to look outside.
To sum it up: no one changes the world by staring at their shoes. The real world-changers have their eye on the horizon.
Tags: dave winer, comparisons are odious, blogging, demotivator